If you’re in the market for a new residence, you may be wondering which is a better investment; the fancy new construction vs. the existing home with the lower price tag. It's similar to buying a car. Which offers better value in the long run, the flashy new sports car or the reliable pre-owned vehicle?
Buying new construction homes has many benefits. Who doesn't love the idea of living in a space equipped with all the latest features that no one has ever lived in before?
However, resale homes offer enticing advantages as well. They offer great value and often have unique layouts and architectural touches that new construction homes may lack. Here are some of the pros and cons of buying new construction vs. resale homes to help you decide which makes sense for you.
Pros of Buying a New Build
Modern Finishes and Amenities
From stainless steel appliances to private outdoor space, modern features and amenities are one of the major benefits of buying new construction. The conveniences and lifestyle new builds offer is what drives up demand and allows developers to charge a higher premium compared to resale homes.
Customization Options
The ability to customize the unit to suit your tastes is another significant benefit of buying a new construction home vs. an existing residence. New builds often offer the ability to customize the layout, interior design, lighting, and other features. How much control you have over the design will depend on the rules of the developer or board, but you certainly have greater flexibility when it comes to customizing a new home vs. an older home.
Less Maintenance
Buying a new home vs. an old residence typically means less maintenance. The structure and systems are newer and therefore shouldn't require as many repairs or upgrades. While it can depend on the quality of the construction, in general new builds require less upkeep and home improvement projects compared to older homes.
Cons of Buying a New Build
Premium Price
One of the major pitfalls of buying a new home vs. an old home is the higher price tag. All those exclusive features and modern upgrades aren't cheap and new builds tend to command a higher premium compared to resale homes with similar characteristics. However, that premium tends to decay over time, which means the additional cost doesn't always translate into long-term value.
Potential for Construction Delays
You may also want to consider construction delays when debating the pros and cons of buying a new construction home vs. a resale property. If it’s still under construction, there’s always the potential that the completion may be delayed. Construction projects rarely go according to plan, so you may need to be patient if you go with the new build.
May Not Live Up to the Hype
Another thing to consider when looking at the pros and cons of new construction homes is whether or not the development will live up to the hype. Just because it's more expensive and promises to offer a luxury lifestyle doesn't guarantee that the property is built to last. There are many examples of new buildings that claim to be top-of-the-line, yet end up suffering from structural problems that impact the basic living experience of residents.
Pros of Buying a Resale Home
Potential Price Savings
A major benefit of buying a resale house vs. new construction is the potential price savings. Resale means the home was previously occupied and therefore isn't brand new. However, it may still offer everything you need to live a comfortable lifestyle. Resale homes tend to be significantly less expensive than comparable new builds, meaning you may get more value for your money.
Established Neighborhood
New builds tend to be found in younger, more up-and-coming neighborhoods that are just beginning to find an identity, whereas resale homes tend to be found in older, more established neighborhoods with a distinct character. While this isn't always the case, historic neighborhoods with a distinct look and feel often put limits on new construction.
More Traditional Layouts Available
Resale homes also tend to feature more traditional layouts and architectural elements compared to new builds. For instance, brownstones are very popular in many parts of New York yet you won't find that type of architectural style in a new build. So consider whether you want a modern aesthetic or timeless charm when choosing between a new home or old home.
Cons of Buying a Resale Home
Older Infrastructure
A major drawback of resale homes is an older infrastructure. Many people think old homes are built better than new construction, however, this isn't always the case. It depends on how old the home is and how good the previous owners were about keeping up with the maintenance. But in general, it will likely have an older roof, plumbing, electrical systems, and other features that may not be up to date with the times.
May Require More Maintenance
Additional maintenance is also something to consider when choosing between new homes versus an old home. One of the major benefits of buying a new home is that it hasn't experienced the same wear and tear as a resale property and, therefore, doesn't require as much ongoing maintenance. While it can depend on the property, new builds are less likely to require unexpected renovations than older homes.
Less Ability to Customize
The lack of customization options is also a disadvantage of buying an old house vs. a new house. Unless you're willing to pay out of pocket or embark on a home renovation project, with a resale home what you see is what you get. That isn't always the case with new builds as the construction process may be ongoing.
New Build vs. Resale Homes: Which Is Right for You?
So, is new construction a good investment? Does it offer the same long-term value as a resale home? The answer depends on your personal tastes and long-term real estate goals. New builds tend to offer convenience, flexibility, and a luxury lifestyle. However, they also tend to be more expensive and don't always live up to expectations.
In contrast, resale homes often offer great value, stability, and a unique character. However, they also may be lacking in modern touches and require more ongoing maintenance.
You may find that the best value lies in homes that are a few years old but don't have a premium price tag. The almost-new, resale homes offer the latest designs, materials, and appliances at a more affordable price.
Buying a home in New York City? Become a member of our New Build Club and get priority access to a massive database of brand-new builds before anyone else. As the authority in new builds, we understand the importance of early access. As a member, we’ll not only show you the best new builds available before they come to market, but we’ll also show you every unit in the building, access floor plans, help you compare prices, and more. Finding your dream home has never been easier. Contact us today at hello@undividedre.com to get started.
